When someone accused of plagiarism responds with explanations involving unintentional copying or "internalizing" or even just coincidence, I usually don't believe them, mostly because of the number of instances per offender. However, I thought I'd share an experience with you, just to keep in the back of your head.
Early in my attempts at fiction, I was paired with a Generous Writer at a conference and had submitted, among other things, a little two-pager thing that included a paragraph describing a mom driving in the evening with two young boys in the back seat. They hit a swarm of lightning bugs. Bugs smeared under the wipers and the windshield glowed and everyone gasped, of course. I'd been inspired by a similar thing with a single lightning bug one evening.
The Generous Writer explained patiently that a lot of writers had used lightning bugs. I nodded and took note.
Some of you, at this point, may know where this is going.
A few months later, GW happened to be in town for an extended period and we'd kept in touch. One evening I asked about the lightning bugs again. "I know about Mark Richard," I said. "But who are some of the others?"
GW replied, "I can't think of them right now, but they're out there." Since I was more curious than disappointed, that answer was just fine by me. I'd keep an eye out.
A month or so later, an out-of-print book by GW arrived and I began to read.
I came across a section describing an elderly woman driving two young boys through a swarm of lightning bugs. One hits and smears on the windshield under the wipers.
I. Was. Mortified.
So I shot off a midnight email apologizing for the awkward positon I must've put the GW in. The email was likely more cringe-inducing than the event that provoked it.
A few weeks later, I went to a GW reading. Afterward, I calmly apologized for the email. GW claimed the email never arrived. *
So last spring I'm reading a new GW collection and suddenly I come across a character with my name who gets struck and killed by a car.
Yes, that last sentence is waaayyy oversimplified but I'm just doing it for fun and to help make a point. I know at least part of that story was written before we ever met. And even if my name *is* borrowed, it'd be hard to find a more flattering character to share a name with.**
What I'm saying is - sometimes this stuff happens. Just not repeatedly. To the same person. In the same piece. Although I'm open to the idea that I'd read the story somewhere, I really don't know where that could've happened - the book was out of print since I'd started writing and even reading more seriously. Maybe it was reprinted somewhere. Still, I'm chalking it up to summer evenings with lots of insects.
Needless to say, that story is dust. Even without the embarrassing part, it'd be gone.
*GW - I don't believe a word of that (in the nicest way) but I appreciate your ability and desire to
rid me of the discomfort. And the recommendations that came after.
**Actually, I *am* mentioned on page 168 (if memory serves) of Dawn of the Vampire by William Hill. Not flattering or unflattering - just gratuitous. But appreciated, especially since many of my other high school friends-as-characters in that book end up dying or turning undead in unsavory ways. It's the kind of one-line thing that would give me a headache if I were an editor.